Competition Heats Up for Circle as Open USD Consortium Emerges
Circle (CRCL) saw a temporary rebound of 5% after a sharp 17% decline, prompting investors to consider the implications of Open USD, a newly formed stablecoin consortium backed by major players like Stripe, Mastercard, Coinbase, and BlackRock. However, global brokerage Jefferies believes that the current risks to Circle have not been fully priced in.
The analyst team at Jefferies has expressed skepticism regarding the potential for recovery, emphasizing that increasing competition from banks, payment processors, and fintech companies launching their own stablecoins is likely to impede USDC's growth and market share. They advised against buying the dip, suggesting that the headwinds facing Circle are unlikely to dissipate soon.
Circle currently holds approximately 25% of the estimated $300 billion stablecoin market. After an initial advantage when it launched in 2018, Circle now faces well-resourced competitors who benefit from extensive distribution networks—an asset Circle lacked in its early days. The entry of Open USD, with participation from over 140 prominent companies, could represent a significant shift in the market dynamics.
The consortium's model, which includes sharing reserve income with its member companies, may appeal to payment service providers and fintechs looking for more collaborative profitability. Jefferies’ analysts turned their focus on Coinbase’s involvement as a potential risk factor, noting that Circle generates about 95% of its revenues from interest on USDC reserves and relies heavily on Coinbase as its primary distribution partner—a relationship reportedly up for renewal in August.
While Jefferies does not believe that Coinbase's move to join Open USD indicates a total pivot away from USDC, they recognize the possibility that Coinbase could, at some point, promote competing stablecoins, thus further complicating USDC's market position.
Circle's CEO Jeremy Allaire openly countered these competitive concerns in a recent post on X, arguing that the stability and efficacy of a stablecoin are rooted in its network, which takes years to cultivate rather than being something that can be easily duplicated. He highlighted USDC's established ecosystem with integrations across countless platforms, substantial liquidity across various exchanges, and regulatory approvals in regions like Europe and Japan as significant barriers for new entrants.
Furthermore, Allaire challenged one of Open USD’s main selling points—the promise of sharing revenue with partners. He claimed that Circle is already sharing a large portion of its income with its partners while maintaining sufficient revenue to continue enhancing its infrastructure. According to Allaire, excessively distributing all income could compromise the robustness of operational capabilities.
He also raised doubts about the efficacy of a consortium approach. Allaire noted, “Larger groups of big companies often struggle with coordination, slow decision-making, and manifest diverging interests, which stifles genuine, sustainable innovation.” His skepticism is echoed by Lorenzo Valente, ARK Invest’s director of digital asset research, who pointed out that multiple consortium-led stablecoin initiatives have historically struggled to achieve meaningful scale.
Valente believes that the success of Open USD may hinge on the ability to coordinate over 140 stakeholders with differing priorities, likening the consortium model to decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) that often face similar governance challenges. He suggested that consensus-driven models might lead to stagnation compared to individual operators who can act more decisively.
Additional doubts linger over whether these expansive organizations would continue to support the initiative under regulatory scrutiny. Circle, along with rivals like Tether, has invested years forging regulatory approvals and infrastructure, suggesting that a consortium might struggle to maintain cohesion in the face of challenging conditions.
Disclosure & Policies: CoinDesk, an award-winning media outlet, adheres to strict editorial guidelines covering the cryptocurrency industry. It is part of Bullish (NYSE:BLSH), providing various digital asset services. CoinDesk's journalists may receive equity-based compensation from Bullish.
